Sign up to The Irish Times Archive (1859 - 2008)My Account »

Sat 04 Apr 2007Silencing the sceptics in some styleEnglish FA Cup Semi-final: Today Manchester Utd v Watford Venue: Villa Park Kick-off: 5.30pm On TV: BBC 1:Inheriting Roy Keane's number 16 shirt at Old Trafford was never an issue for Michael Carrick, writes Daniel Taylor.For a player who passes the ball as beautifully as Michael Carrick, it is strange how scepticism has attached itself to him at every club. At West Ham he was thought of as the rosebud that never properly flowered. At Tottenham the fans likened him to Glenn Hoddle, yet complained that he still fell short. And in his early days at Manchester United there was an obsession with his £18 million price tag and serious misgivings about whether he was equipped to take over from a once-in-a-lifetime legend such as Roy Keane.