Sign up to The Irish Times Archive (1859 - 2008)My Account »

Fri 12 Dec 2006US judge has doubts on prisoner actionA US judge expressed doubt on Friday that Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld could be held personally liable for the abuse of Iraqi and Afghan prisoners, including at Abu Ghraib.US District Chief Judge Thomas Hogan said that while torture is unacceptable, he was not sure whether the nine Iraqi and Afghan residents had a right to sue Mr Rumsfeld in US courts.